Lead quality checklist: 18 steps from contract to week ten (free Excel)

Test the leads an agency or AI tool sends you: a written definition, four checks per lead and an acceptance log. 18 steps, free Excel, no form.

11 min Measuring outbound

Twenty of the 30 sites we read don't say what counts as a qualified lead, and 26 don't say what happens to one that fails. So the test is yours: set down what a good lead is before the pilot, check each one you're sent, and count what the good ones turn into.

This is for the founder who still sells, or the sales or export manager beside them, running a pilot with an outbound agency or an AI sales tool. You get 18 steps, a definition to copy and a log that does the sums.

How we put this together. On 14 November 2026 we read the public pages of 30 sites selling leads, meetings or outbound programmes to B2B companies: 23 agencies and 7 AI sales tools. The count, the steps, the stop rule and the log are our own.

The acceptance log: how do you check whether delivered leads are any good?

Set the definition in writing before the pilot starts. Then check each delivered lead against the company register, its website and LinkedIn, log it as accepted or rejected with a reason and a date, and judge the pilot by the conversations its accepted leads start.

In our research into published buyer's guides on lead quality, the most detailed test asks the vendor for 200 to 500 contacts that match your ideal customer profile, to check yourself. It's written for SaaS teams (read 14 November 2026). In a market of 150 companies, that sample is more than exists, and on 20 leads each one moves the accepted share by 5 points.

So check fewer leads, more closely, and stop at the first check that fails: that's the reason you log. Only accepted leads count, so the pilot's number divides by them.

The lead quality checklist: 18 steps

Five phases, from before you sign to week 10. The Excel file adds the contract dates, the sums and an invented pilot.

Download the free lead quality checklist and acceptance log (Excel)

First tab of the lead quality Excel file: pilot details to fill in, the three lines that say what a good lead is, and the stop rule

You is the founder or the one salesperson who owns the pilot; Vendor is the agency or AI tool. An office manager can run steps 7 to 9, but the verdict stays with you.

Phase 1: Before you sign

#StepWhoWhenDone
1Write the definition in three lines: the company (type, size, country, active in its register), the person (the role that decides), the next step (what they agreed to)YouBefore the first sales call☐
2Put the definition in the agreement itself, not a slideYouBefore signing☐
3Ask for 10 to 20 sample leads from your own market and run steps 7 to 10 on themYou, VendorBefore signing☐
4Get the rejection terms in writing: a window in working days, who has final say, replace or creditYouBefore signing☐
5Put the minimum term and the notice date on the pilot calendarYouThe day you sign☐
6Agree who keeps the list, the mailbox and the replies at the endYouBefore signing☐

In our research into published agency contract guides, the whole contract rests on its definition of a qualified lead, and the question to settle is who has final say when you dispute whether a lead met it. For step 4, the most detailed buyer's guide asks for a rejection window of at least 10 business days. For step 6 and more questions: agency, AI sales agent or yourself and your first sales hire. If the agreement matters, have your own lawyer read it.

Phase 2: Each delivered lead, inside the rejection window

#StepWhoWhenDone
7Company real and active: look it up in the official registerYouDay of delivery☐
8Company fits the definition: type and size from the register or the websiteYouDay of delivery☐
9The right person, still in that role: company website, LinkedInYouDay of delivery☐
10For a reply or a meeting: the person agreed to a next stepYouDay of delivery☐
11Log accept or reject, the reason and the dateYouSame day☐
12Send the rejects, with reasons, in one batchYou, VendorBefore the window closes☐

Registers by country: Europages, Kompass or a company register? Before you write to a company yourself: our company research checklist.

Phase 3: Week 4

#StepWhoWhenDone
13Count the accepted share and the reasons; a reason that repeats changes the definition or the vendor's briefYou, VendorWeek 4☐
14Count conversations started per accepted leadYouWeek 4, then weekly☐

A conversation starts when an accepted lead replies to you or takes your call and asks for or agrees to a next step, as in our outbound scorecard.

Phase 4: Before the notice date

#StepWhoWhenDone
15Do the sums: cost per delivered lead, per accepted lead, per conversationYouA week before notice☐
16Decide by the stop rule you wrote in week 1: go on, change the definition, or give noticeYouBy the notice date☐

Phase 5: Week 10

#StepWhoWhenDone
17Get the list and the reply history in a format you can useYou, VendorWeek 10☐
18Write what you learned into the definition for the next routeYouWeek 10☐
See the register and LinkedIn checks HAL, gethal.ai's AI sales agent, runs before anyone is contacted. Book a demo

What do agencies and AI tools publish about lead quality?

Too little to sign on. Of the 30 sites, 10 define a qualified lead or meeting, 4 say what happens to a delivered lead that doesn't meet the definition, 6 offer a free sample, trial or pilot, and 15 state a minimum term or that there is none. None publishes all four.

All 10 definitions are on agency sites; none of the 7 AI tools has one. Samples run the other way: 4 of the 7 tools offer one, against 2 of the 23 agencies. Sites were picked by search, European first (20 of 30), and only public pages were read, so the count shows what a buyer sees before a sales call, not anyone's leads.

What the 10 definitions ask for

Part of the definitionDefinitions, of 10
The person or role9
Company fit8
A stated need or interest8
A booked or held meeting4
Timing4
Budget1
A check of the company in a public register0

You add the register check yourself, in step 7.

What the 4 rejection policies say

One gives the client 30 days from delivery, after which leads are deemed accepted. Another has the vendor confirm a challenge. Both answers belong in step 4.

A worked example: a ten-week pilot, 40 leads

Every name and number here is invented. A maker of industrial sensors pays an outbound agency €6,000 for a ten-week pilot in Germany, Denmark and Sweden: 4 leads every Monday from 11 January 2027.

The definition, as the company wrote it in week 1:

  1. The company: builds pressure or temperature sensors into its own machines; 20 to 250 employees; in Germany, Denmark or Sweden; active in its official register.
  2. The person: the head of engineering, the head of purchasing or the managing director, in that role today.
  3. The next step: they asked the agency for a datasheet, a sample or a call about a named machine.

Our stop rule for this pilot: by the notice date, go on if at least half the delivered leads are accepted and they've started at least 1 conversation per 10 accepted. If one reason causes most rejects, change the definition first. Otherwise, give notice.

The first five rows of its log:

#LeadDelivered7 Register8 Fit9 Person10 Next stepVerdictReasonConversation started
1Muster Prüftechnik GmbH, DE11 JanYesYesYesYesAccept20 Jan
2Eksempel Maskiner ApS, DK11 JanNoRejectNot active in the register
3Beispiel Anlagenbau GmbH, DE11 JanYesYesYesYesAccept
4Exempel Automation AB, SE11 JanYesYesNoRejectPerson left the role
5Eksempel Procesudstyr A/S, DK18 JanYesYesYesYesAccept27 Jan

The contract, signed 4 January 2027, has a three-month minimum term to 3 April and 30 days' notice, so notice is due by 4 March 2027, in week 8. The first 10-working-day rejection window closes on 25 January (week 3), the week-4 count is on 1 February and the last delivery on 15 March.

Calendar of the invented ten-week pilot: weekly deliveries from 11 January 2027, the first rejection window closing 25 January, the week-4 count on 1 February and notice due 4 March, in week 8, with 8 of 40 leads still to come
Notice falls due in week 8, before the last 8 leads arrive. Invented example, from the contract dates above.

In week 4, half the rejects named someone who had left the role, so the company asked the agency to confirm roles on LinkedIn. On 4 March the invented log held 32 leads, 21 accepted and 4 conversations, about 1 per 5 accepted, so the company went on. After ten weeks:

MeasureSumResult
Accepted share26 of 40 delivered (14 rejected)65%
Cost per delivered lead€6,000 ÷ 40€150
Cost per accepted lead€6,000 ÷ 26€231
Cost per conversation€6,000 ÷ 6€1,000
Conversations per accepted lead6 ÷ 260.23, about 1 in 4
Bring your pilot's numbers to a demo, and we'll show you what HAL hands over for each company. Book a demo

How does the check change by case?

The four checks stay. What moves is where you look hardest: at the next step when the vendor delivers meetings, at the definition when an AI tool delivers contacts, at every lead when the market is small, and at the right register when the leads cross borders.

When the vendor delivers meetings, not leads

Step 10 is the whole check: did the person agree to the meeting, and did it happen? Agree before signing what happens to a no-show.

When an AI tool delivers contacts

Write your definition before the free trial ends, and use the trial as step 3. Step 10 waits until you've written to the contact yourself.

When the market is 50 companies, not 500

Every reject is a name you may not get back. Check every lead, and give the vendor your customers and open deals to exclude.

Across several countries

Use each country's register. Bolagsverket shows a Swedish company's status free. Companies House lists current and resigned officers free, but its search service "does not check the accuracy of the information filed". Read 11 and 12 November 2026.

Three mistakes that undo the checklist

A replacement lead is not a better lead

Ask where the replacement comes from; if it's the same list and targeting, expect the same rejects. When a reason repeats, change the brief.

A pilot judged on volume hides the rejects

In our research into published guides to AI sales agent pilots, the most common mistake named is measuring only volume, emails sent and meetings booked, and ignoring quality: show rate, meetings that turn into opportunities, pipeline created. They plan for 90 days at a sales team's volume. In the example, 40 leads arrived on time and 14 were rejected.

The notice date falls before the results do

In the example, 2 of the 6 conversations started after notice was due. Decide on what the log shows by then, and ask before signing for a notice date after the last delivery.

Take the 18 steps and the log with you: Download the 18-step lead quality checklist (Excel).

Where HAL fits

HAL, gethal.ai's AI sales agent, is one more route for the same log. It works in five stages, find, research, qualify, quality control and draft, with no send stage. It checks leads against public registries (CVR, proff.dk) and LinkedIn before anyone is contacted. For each company it writes an outreach brief and a suggested first email.

HAL doesn't send anything: you send from your own mailbox, and the replies and the conversations you count in step 14 come to you. Meetings, demos, quotes and negotiation stay with you. Log its companies like an agency's, with a reason for every reject. To see what it hands over, book a demo or look at the plans.

Bring your three-line definition to a demo, and ask which of its checks HAL runs for you. Book a demo

FAQ

What should count as a qualified lead in a lead generation contract?

Three lines: the company (type, size, country, active in its official register), the person who decides and the next step they agreed to, written into the agreement itself.

Can I reject leads from a lead generation agency?

Your right to reject depends on the terms you agree, so get them in writing before you sign: a rejection window in working days, who has final say, and replace or credit. Of 30 agency and AI sales tool sites we read on 14 November 2026, 4 publish what happens to a lead that fails.

How many leads should I test before I trust an agency?

Check the first 20 by hand against the register, the company's website and LinkedIn. In a market of a few hundred companies, check every lead.

Should a lead generation agency send sample leads before I sign?

Yes: ask for 10 to 20 from your own market and run the four checks on them. Of the 30 sites we read, 6 offer a free sample, trial or pilot.

How do I know if a lead is real?

Check the company is active in its official register, such as Companies House (UK), CVR (Denmark) or Bolagsverket (Sweden), then confirm on its website and LinkedIn that the person still holds the role.

Write your three lines first

Then log every lead from the first delivery. To see the checks HAL runs before anyone is contacted, book a demo.

Keep reading: Outbound agency, AI sales agent or doing it yourself · Outbound scorecard template · Company research checklist

What changed: nothing yet

More posts

All posts →

Book a demo

Tell us about your sales motion, and we'll show you HAL running on your pipeline.

Managed for you, zero setup. Your data stays in your own tenant. DPA available. Already a customer? Log in →