Outbound scorecard template: replies, interest and meetings, not opens (free Excel and PDF)

How do you know if your cold outreach is working? A free weekly scorecard (Excel, PDF) that counts companies, replies, interest and meetings, not opens.

11 min Measuring outbound

Apple Mail, with Protect Mail Activity on, fetches an email's images in the background as the message arrives, and classic Outlook blocks them by default. So your email tool's open rate can count reads that never happened and miss reads that did. Count four things a week instead: companies contacted, companies that replied, replies asking for a next step, and meetings.

This is for the founder who still sells, or the sales or export manager beside them, writing to 30–60 companies a month and unsure what a quiet week means. You'll leave with a weekly log, a filled example and a way to read small numbers.

How we put this together. We read Apple's, Microsoft's and Google's help pages and published reply data on 12 November 2026; the scorecard, ranges and example are ours.

The outbound scorecard: a weekly log to copy

Download the free outbound scorecard (Excel) · PDF (A4) · PDF (US Letter)

One row a week, and one per list if you work two. Copy the table, or use the Excel file.

Week startingList or marketNew companies contactedEmails sentCompanies that repliedInterested repliesMeetings bookedMeetings heldAsked not to be contactedNotes

Each rate is over the last 4 weeks: reply rate is companies that replied ÷ new companies contacted; interested per company is interested replies ÷ new companies contacted; then meetings booked ÷ interested replies. The Excel file adds interested share of replies and emails per company. Its Summary tab covers the quarter and the total to date, with a plausible range for the interested rate. The PDF has 13 empty rows and a box for three rates by hand.

See how HAL finds and checks the companies that go into your first row. Book a demo

What is each column for?

Each column counts something a buyer did, per company, so every rate divides by the buyers you reached. Replies, interested replies and meetings are three steps towards a sale. Opt-outs stop you writing to someone twice, and the notes turn the counts back into names to act on.

ColumnWhat countsWhy
A. Week startingThe Monday, as a date13 rows make a quarter
B. List or marketWhich list the companies came from, e.g. "UK, plant engineering"Each list read on its own
C. New companies contactedCompanies that got their first email this week. A company counts once per listThe divisor for every rate
D. Emails sentEvery email this week, first ones and follow-upsHow hard you follow up
E. Companies that repliedCompanies where a person answered this week, whatever the answer. Auto-replies and bounces don't countA person read it
F. Interested repliesOf E: the reply asks for or agrees to a next step (a call, a meeting, a visit, a price, a sample)A "no" is a reply too
G. Meetings bookedMeetings or calls agreed this weekThe step a sale needs
H. Meetings heldMeetings or calls that took place this weekSome booked meetings fall through
I. Asked not to be contactedCompanies that asked you to stop; never write to them againNobody hears from you twice
J. NotesWhich companies replied or are interested; what you changed this weekNames for Monday
No opens columnNothingMail apps make opens (next section)

Column E counts replies as the largest dataset in our research does (the reply-rate table below); F keeps interest apart, as another dataset there does. The rest is our method.

People, not pixels: why the scorecard has no opens column

An open is typically recorded when a mail app loads a tracking pixel, a small image in your email, whoever or whatever made it load. Apple, Microsoft and Google each document how that can differ from a person reading.

  • Apple Mail. Apple says Protect Mail Activity "downloads remote content in the background by default", and its Mail guide says this happens "when a message is received". So an email can count as opened before anyone has read it.
  • Classic Outlook. Microsoft says "Microsoft Outlook is configured by default to block automatic picture downloads from the Internet", partly to help readers avoid "tracking pixels: invisible images that can tell a sender you've read the email". A buyer can read it there and record no open.
  • Gmail. Google says "Sometimes, senders may know whether you've opened an email that has an image", and readers can choose "Ask before displaying external images".

So an open rate can be wrong in both directions, and you can't tell which way for any one buyer. Replies, interested replies and meetings each need a person.

A filled example, with invented numbers

The company and every number here are invented. A 25-person maker of dust-extraction systems writes to 10 furniture factories a week, alternating UK and German lists, with two follow-ups unless it hears back.

WeekListNew companiesEmailsRepliedInterestedBookedHeldOpt-outsNotes
7 SepUK101000000
14 SepGermany101910001Asked us to stop
21 SepUK102721000Interested: a price. Someone else
28 SepGermany102810100Call booked. Not now: spring
5 OctUK102921010Call held. Interested: a visit. A no
12 OctGermany102910101Visit booked. Asked us to stop
19 OctUK102911010Visit held. Interested: a call
26 OctGermany102910000Someone else: the plant manager
Total8020093222

In the Summary tab:

FigureSumResult
Reply rate9 ÷ 8011%
Interested per company3 ÷ 803.75%, plausible range 1.3% to 10.5%
Meetings booked per interested reply2 ÷ 32 of 3
Companies contacted per meeting booked80 ÷ 240

On the Monday after, the founder works from the notes: a date for the call the 19 October company agreed to, a first email to the plant manager, and spring in the diary for the "not now". The interested rate could sit anywhere from about 1 in 78 to 1 in 10, so it waits for the quarter.

See the outreach brief and suggested first email HAL writes for each company. Book a demo

How do you fill in the scorecard each week?

Take about ten minutes on Monday for last week's row. Count each company once, in the week of its first email. Log each reply in the week it arrives and sort it before counting, then add meetings and opt-outs. Read the 4-week figures only once the row is done, and against your own last quarter.

  1. Companies: follow-ups count in emails sent only.
  2. Replies: sort each as interested, not now, someone else, no, or auto-reply, which isn't counted. A company that writes twice is one reply.
  3. Meetings: one booked this week and held next week appears in both rows.
  4. Opt-outs: note them so nobody writes again. Check the email rules for each market with your own lawyer.

The Summary tab's companies per meeting booked fills line 4 of the sum in How to find new buyers between trade fairs.

What is a good reply rate for cold email?

In our research, average reply rates for cold email run from 0.45% to 7.0% of emails sent. Each comes from one company's campaigns or one platform's users and counts something different, so compare with your own last quarter, per company contacted.

What we foundSampleWhat it counts
0.45%; founders and owners 0.57%7,530,489 emails, one company's campaigns in 2025Unique replies ÷ emails sent, no auto-replies or bounces
3.43%; top quarter 5.5% or moreOne platform's users, 1 January to 18 December 2025, count not givenAverage reply rate, divisor not stated
7.0% response rate; interest rate 1.7%87,015 B2B emails, one company's own campaigns, period not givenResponses ÷ emails, including referrals and requests to reconnect later; interest divisor not stated
6.2% at 21–50 recipients per sequence; 2.4% at 500 or more31 million emails, one platform's users, 2025Reply rate by recipients per sequence

All four were published in 2026. Put on one month of yours, 40 companies with three emails each, the lowest rate gives 0.54 replies from 120 emails and the highest gives 8.4, about 15.6 times as many. Part of that gap is what each one counts: unique replies from a person on one side, every response on the other.

How many companies before the rates mean anything?

More than one month gives you. With 40 companies, 2 interested replies fit a true rate anywhere from about 1 in 70 to 1 in 6, by our arithmetic. Four times as many companies roughly halves that spread, so at 30–60 companies a month, a quarter is the shortest stretch worth reading as a rate.

Interested repliesCompanies contactedRatePlausible range (Wilson, 95%)
1402.5%0.4% to 12.9%
2405.0%1.4% to 16.5%
2306.7%1.8% to 21.3%
44010.0%4.0% to 23.1%
81605.0%2.6% to 9.6%
204005.0%3.3% to 7.6%

Each row is our own arithmetic on invented numbers; the Summary tab works out the same range for yours. So read rows weekly and rates quarterly. Act on the rows each week; read the rates against your last quarter.

Where to look when one number is low

Change one thing at a time and give it a quarter, or you won't know which change did it.

What you seeLook first at
Few repliesThe list, and your reason for writing to each company
Replies, little interestWhether the companies fit, and what you offer
Interest, few meetingsHow fast you answer, and the next step you ask for
Meetings booked, not heldConfirmations, and who takes the meeting

The company research checklist and the first cold email template help with the first row.

What people get wrong

An email count hides how many companies you reached

Every follow-up adds to emails sent, so follow-ups look like reach. Divide by companies.

A reply isn't interest

A "not now" and a request to stop are replies too. Count only next-step replies as interested.

A subject line judged by opens is judged by mail apps

The winner by open rate can be the one that reached more mail apps fetching images on arrival. Judge by interested replies per company.

One quiet week is a small number, not a verdict

At 10 companies a week, a week with no interested reply says little: in the example, five of eight weeks had none.

Where HAL fits

HAL, gethal.ai's AI sales agent, is one way to run the work this scorecard measures, in stages: find, research, qualify, quality control and draft. It checks leads against public registries (CVR, the official Danish register; proff.dk, a company-data site) and LinkedIn, then writes an outreach brief and a suggested first email for each company. HAL doesn't send anything: you send from your own mailbox, the replies come to you, and you log each one in your scorecard.

HAL can't meet a buyer, run a demo or negotiate a price: meetings, demos, quotes and negotiation stay with you, and so do the meeting columns. Saga, the CRM, and vitr, the dashboard, are included, and the scorecard works the same without HAL. To see HAL on one of your markets, book a demo.

Ask us which steps HAL would take on in your markets, and which stay with you. Book a demo

Who this is for

  • The founder who still sells: the log, the Monday steps and the ranges.
  • The sales or export manager: the column definitions and the published rates.
  • Running a pilot with an agency or an AI sales agent: this log is the record for step 3 of Test one market before you commit.

FAQ

Are email open rates still accurate after Apple Mail Privacy Protection?

Not reliably, in either direction. Apple says Protect Mail Activity downloads remote content in the background by default, so an email can count as opened unread. Microsoft says classic Outlook blocks automatic picture downloads by default, so a read can go unrecorded.

What counts as a positive or interested reply in cold email?

One that asks for or agrees to a next step: a call, a meeting, a visit, a price or a sample. Decide that before counting, and leave auto-replies out.

How many meetings should cold outreach book?

Work it out from your own record rather than a target: companies contacted ÷ meetings booked. In our invented example, that's 40. Read it over a quarter and plan from it.

Should I turn off open tracking in cold email?

The scorecard doesn't need it. Every column counts something a person did, so it reads the same whether tracking is on or off.

How do I measure outbound when I only contact a few companies a month?

Count companies, not emails, and log replies, interested replies and meetings each week. Act on the names weekly and read the rates quarterly. At 40 companies a month, one reply moves a rate by 2.5 points.

Start the log this Monday

Fill in last week's row today. To see HAL find and check the companies in your rows and draft the first email to each, book a demo or look at the plans.

Keep reading: Finding buyers between trade fairs · Agency, AI sales agent or yourself · First cold email template

What changed: nothing yet

More posts

All posts →

Book a demo

Tell us about your sales motion, and we'll show you HAL running on your pipeline.

Managed for you, zero setup. Your data stays in your own tenant. DPA available. Already a customer? Log in →